AI Bubble: The Obsession With Dot-Com And The Next Big Short
Investors are obsessed with comparing the current AI bull market with the 2000's dot-com crash. At this rate I cannot open X without seeing a fractal or cycle chart of the 2000 Nasdaq top being compared or overlayed with the present day NDX, SOXX, or SMH chart.
This is nothing new though. Going all the way back to my beginnings in investing in 2010, each and every tech rally both small and large has drawn these comparisons and yet none of them have come to fruition. So outside of pure fear mongering and engagement farming what is the obsession with constantly attempting to top tick the market?
Michael Burry and others romanticized short selling in the late 2000's with famous bets against MBS and the stock market as a whole. Obviously this was a monster trade and credit where credit is due however people often forget how difficult a trade like this is to pull off, even with luck at your side.
Beyond that they forget that short selling is a tool, and that tool was not designed with the intent of being constantly used to bet against the stock market. Remember, asset prices move higher 75-80% of the time over a given period. An old saying on Wall St. goes: "Far more money has been lost trying to call a top or avoid a bear market then there ever was from buying the top" and that cannot be more true.
So why is there always such an appetite for trying to avoid the next big drawdown or for betting against a raging bull? Well aside from natural things such as fear, (which is the most pervasive emotion and what causes people to panic when they otherwise wouldn't) I believe that the rush to skepticism in the politically dominant demographic is caused by the embedded memory of the lost decade in the 2000's.
When you look at a chart of the S&P from that era, you can see how investors suffered through 2 major bear markets in less than a 10 year span. Those who bought in March 2000 did not break even until thirteen years later in 2013. Not only that, but they had to endure the torture of a failed brief new high in 2007 which of course only led to more tears over the next 18 months. This is not something that bears no consequences. It embeds a zeitgeist into a generation, and the meta for that generation is one of "you always have to be on the lookout for the next crash".
However is incredibly abnormal historically speaking and looking back now, most drawdowns of the past can barely even register on a monthly chart:

But do they have a point this time? They are some incredibly scary fractals in regards to tech sector today and the tech sector of 20 years ago. Let's look at the data: The Dot-Com Fractal: Source: @0xPhantomDefi X.com


Source: @redpill_finance X.com

These fractals make for very convincing arguments as they mirror each other with a eerily similar patterns. As they say, history repeats and so do market cycles. But... are we just cherry picking the data? What Other Fractals Say: Source: @Barchart Facebook.com

This projection from this past September has us almost on the same path as late 1999 - early 2000. It appears to be tracking incredibly well and we even had the melt up this past April which would in theory coincide with the Q1 '00 blow off. Sounds scary right? Let's look at the chart below:
Source: @Michael_Wang Tradingview.com

This fractal suggests that a massive blow off rally in the Nasdaq would begin in early 2022, It used the exact same timeframe (Q4 '99 -Q1 '00) as the previous graph did, and it also tracked incredibly well... until it didn't.
Now let's look at two more fractals who have already come and gone:

The first coincides with how 2021-2022 actually ended up playing out. You can see a similar M-top type structure to the present day chart picture below pictured above (chart 2.) The second fractal resembles that of 2024 into Q1 2025:

Again, you can clearly see the resemblance. M-top structure (just like 2026!) but the results could not be more different. Now to be fair, both of these fractals did end up resolving lower. 2022 was of course the worst while 2025 was simply a minor blip before a massive moonshot rally. However the bigger point is that neither of these examples above resulted in anything remotely close to the dot-com meltdown from 2000-2003. In fact, as the aforementioned old saying on Wall St. goes, one could have bought the exact high in each of these instances and still come out filthy rich within 12-24 months later. This post is not about dismissing cycles or fractals. In fact I have an entire course on time and cycle analysis myself and use those strategies daily. However they are not an automatic cheat code, nothing in the market ever is. Cycles can and will fail just like a bull flag on a chart can fail. It's the nature of the game. That's not to dismiss any of the evidence above, it's to remember to stay grounded and prepared for what happens if you are wrong (or early). Other points to consider: Source: @JC_ParetsX X.com

The percentage of households who pay for AI is currently just a miniscule 2.2% as of July 2026. For perspective, NVDA's full 2026 FY revenue stood at $216B and is projected to be between $411 - $417B next year. This is with just 2.2% of Americans paying for AI. What happens when that number inevitably reaches 10, 20, or 50%? I get it, its not a perfect comparison and its not meant to be. We can talk about token costs, we can talk about Anthropic, Open AI, and others who have a host of their own problems (and of course as of me writing this NVDA now has some decisions to make what with Jensen Huang's personal side quests and all) but I think it is worth putting these types of things into perspective. With everything being said, I don't want to sound like a dismissive arrogant perma-bull. One of my best calls ever was shorting the indexes, semi's, and tech during the last week of December 2021. From there I stayed pre-dominantly short throughout most of 2022 and that happened to be my best year ever in terms of swing trading returns, so I am no stranger to playing the bear side. On the other hand, it seems that for a while now that whether they participated in it or not, a growing amount of investors believe that AI is a bubble and will end exactly they that dot-com did. The Skeptics are now the cheerleaders: On skepticism - isn't it ironic how the story changes? Source: Gemini (When asked About NVDA and AI Skepticism in 2023)


Retail traders and even many analysts were quick to tell us that you risked buying the top all the way back in 2023 but now after NVDA has fallen 40% in just over one month they all have rushed in to buy the dip: Source: @DeItaone

Closing Thoughts:
Maybe this is a sign that the bull run is indeed over - the skeptics have all finally bought in despite not believing for the majority of the ride up! Maybe it just means that people love to think that they are smart for going against the crowd, and thus they take the opposite position to whatever they think the narrative is.
I'll let you decide for yourself however I'll leave you with this: As someone who has studied stock market cycles, I have never seen a cycle mirror perfectly for more than 9-12 months before falling off the tracks. If things were that easy, we'd all just buy and sell every turn in the current cycle that is being repeated and everyone would be rich. It just doesn't work that way.
Furthermore, the odds that the powers that be would allow for another dot-com like drawdown of 90% or more across most mega caps as well as the Nasdaq itself are incredibly low in this post GFC, QE world that we are in. Not that it needs to be explained but just look at a chart of the S&P 500 with US tax receipts overlaying it.
Hint, they are the same chart:

To wrap things up, I am not saying that we cannot ever have another large drawdown. I am not saying that that AI isn't a bubble or that there aren't similarities between present day tech and the dot-com era, or that history can't or won't repeat. I am saying that having a different perspective on things is healthy, and reminding everyone that the biggest graveyard on Wall St. is occupied by those who tried fighting a bull market for too long. In the end, fractals and cycles are a tool and a powerful one that that however they will always break off at some point and often do so at the worst time imaginable. I am speaking from experience on this. 🔐For access to premium trading content including swing trade alerts & live day trading room visit 👉 - https://www.carnivoretrades.com/
🎥 Youtube - @carnivoretrades (Live streams, shorts, trading tips) 🎥 Youtube - @gammaboytrading (Daily market analysis)
🐦X - @aaronbasile
📷Instagram - @carnivoretrades
✍️Substack - @carnivoretrades




Comments